• Skip to Content
  • Skip to Channel Navigation
  • Skip to Information Links
  • Skip to Accessibility Information
HR Magazine LogoHR Magazine
  • Home
  •  
  • News
  •  
  • Features
  •  
  • HR TV
  •  
  • Suppliers
  •  
  • Solutions
  •  
  • Forums & Blogs
  •  
  • White Papers
  •  
  • Employee Benefits
  •  
  • Learning & Development
  •  
  • Employment Law
  •  
  • Recruitment
  •  
  • HR People
  •  
  • Research
  •  
  • Technology & Metrics
  •  
 
16 March 2010
  • Home:
  • Tribunal rules length of service can be considered when deciding redundancies in Rolls-Royce case
Tribunal rules length of service can be considered when deciding redundancies in Rolls-Royce case

Tribunal rules length of service can be considered when deciding redundancies in Rolls-Royce case

David Woods, 18 May 2009

 

Be the first to comment on this article

The Court of Appeal has ruled that employers can award points to staff for years of service as a benefit, to consider when making redundancy decisions.

 

The ruling in the case of Rolls-Royce v Unite found giving staff points in this way, as Rolls-Royce did, was not necessarily unlawful age discrimination as it could be objectively justified. Rolls-Royce wanted to discontinue the practice, but the union argued in favour of it.

Rachel Dineley, head of the diversity and discrimination unit at law firm Beachcroft, said: "The court agreed with Unite and this case is a win for many older employees. In difficult economic times most employers wish to have maximum flexibility in determining who to retain and who to let go, but collective agreements may govern the matter.

"In light of this decision, employers who historically have included points for length of service in their redundancy selection process may encounter difficulty in abandoning the practice to allow a wider pool of choice for redundancies."

Age discrimination legislation currently permits employers to use length of service as a factor when rewarding employee benefits, provided more than five years of service is taken into account - and this does not apply only to tangible benefits such as pay and annual leave.

Dineley pointed out the ruling was not an endorsement of a ‘last in, first out' approach to redundancy. But she added: "While the decision gives clarity to the law, it still leaves plenty of scope for negotiation between employers and their workforce."

X

You must login to use Clip & Save

  • Print
  • Email
  • Clip &
    Save
  • News
    by email
 

Share:

  • Bookmark on...
  • Del.icio.us
  • Stumble It!
  • Facebook
  • Reddit
  • DIGG
  • Google
  • Yahoo
 

Your Comment

 
 

To post comments please log in here

 

All Comments

There are currently no comments.

Related Media

Rolls' class act

Most employers do not understand redundancy laws, making them liable for penalties

Jobs boost at Rolls-Royce as the firm recruits 150

Staff who fabricate claims against their employer must pay legal costs, Tribunal rules

London Borough of Hackney has more ethnic minority staff among its high earners than any other council

Male staff win landmark equal pay case

Latest News

Pay inconsistency is damaging staff retention

National Audit Office produces report to improve understanding of public-sector pensions

National Association of Pension Funds sets out steps Government must take to fix the UK's pension system

 
News By Email

Poll

Do you think a 21-hour working week will work to tackle issues such as overwork, unemployment, high carbon emissions, low wellbeing, inequalities and sustainability?

 

Directory

 

Latest Issue

Latest Issue

March 2010

Line managers are less critical of HR than they were a year ago - will this continue?

B&Q's HR director explains the company's focus on 18-24 year-olds

Can the science of analytics create super workforce planning?

CSR must be seen as an investment, not a business cost

 

 

Subscribe
 

ADVERTISEMENT

Skip to Main Navigation
Haymarket

Haymarket © 1957 – 2010

  • About Us
  • Register
  • News By Email
  • Advertising
  • Contact Us
  • Sitemap
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy
  • Accessibility
  • News
  • Features
  • Reviews
  • Management Today
 
  • Contact Us
  • News By Email
  • Advertising
  • Subscriptions
  • Newsfeeds
  • Sitemap
  • My HR
  • register
  • Log In