News

Out with Luddites, HR needs to become irresistible, says Westminster council chief

David Woods, 20 May 2011

Graham White

HR hasn’t got much longer to go, as HR directors are struggling to work to a model that no longer exists. It needs to reinvent itself, and fast. That was the revelation Graham White (pictured), HR director at Westminster City Council, shared with fellow HR professionals at the Human Resources Forum on board the cruise ship Aurora yesterday.

White, who compared HR directors to the Luddites who unsuccessfully attempted to prevent the industrial revolution of the 19th century, said: “Organisations used to have a director of electricity. This role was removed when electricity became a natural part of businesses. The future of HR is short, because the role is short – not because we are no good. HR is only 106 years old; businesses coped before it, so how can we ensure we remain?

“The secret is not for HR departments to be liked – but to become irresistible. My department is one of the most hated in the council, by staff, but my desire to be irresistible to the business has overtaken my desire to be liked.

“There is no looking back – innovation is moving us on. HR directors cannot be a narrow specialised body and survival will be about a change in the whole philosophy. We will not become irresistible by dealing with staff absence and payroll. There is just no future for people with narrow technical abilities.”

White said his HR department has created a recruitment strategy to empower line managers in the council to recruit their own staff. “Automation never affects managers,” he said. “They can still do their jobs. But it affects HR. We won’t disappear, but we need to come up with new ideas to replace the resistible things [such as recruitment] when society moves on.”

Commenting on the public sector cuts, White admitted 2,500 employees at the council were in a state of vulnerability, meaning they were facing the possibility of redundancy.

“We have never had to make people redundant before,” he said. “But my policy to staff is that everything I hear from the board, they will know too. I created an HR hotline for staff to ask questions, and the number is easy for me to remember – it’s my direct line.”

Closing his session, White challenged delegates to ask themselves the question ‘if HR had never existed, would anyone have noticed?’

He adapted a quote of fictional character Nanny McPhee, making the point strikingly relevant to HR: “As far as HR and business is concerned – when you need me but don’t want me, I will stay, but when you want me but don’t need me, then I have to go.”

3 comments on this article

Your comment

Click here to comment

Irresistible can be interpreted in a number of ways

Chris Smith 20 May 2011

–adjective 1. not resistible; incapable of being resisted or withstood: an irresistible impulse. 2. lovable, especially calling forth feelings of protective love: an irresistible puppy. 3. enticing; tempting to possess: an irresistible necklace.

Out with Luddites

Nicholas Carson 20 May 2011

HR is being used as a crutch by ineffective management - HR is today as Unions used to be - a necessary evil to compensate for the lack of fair empathetic management who communicate openly and honestly and who treat their employees with consideration and compassion. Once Management starts living up to its responsibilities with all employees HR should be irrelevant.

Out with Luddites - HR to change

Nikki Mears 24 May 2011

This is exactly the problem in any organisation today. HR has become a cumbersome hurdle, making the whole function too complicated for the employees and managers to actually find easily, understand and use. Having worked in this arena for many years in a large organisation. the one common problem is that HR try to fix all the needs around Skills and Talent Management, whereas they should actually focus on HR being a functional element that focuses on the corporate necessities and leaves the reality of skills management to the business themselves. However, with the lack of simplistic solutions within organisations AND the lack of understanding that management have on managing skills and Talent, you are then faced with another dilemma on how can you provide a simplistic solution that both the employees and the managers can easily integrate into their daily routines. All is not lost, as we have delivered solutions that can provide this complete service and have managed such programmes within business areas within large organisations, cost effectively and simplistically. So in short, to manage this change it will take real people to accept their shortfalls, adjust their focus and embrace new ways of working. New does not have to mean investment in new products or massive implementations into the existing infrastructure. Change can happen overnight by unlocking hidden assets that aleady exist within the business and making them visible and usable to the end user!

Latest Issue - May 2012

MA Business & Leisure Limited © Copyright 2012, All Rights Reserved