Features

Leadership and humility: a more humane approach to business

Ken Starkey, 31 Jan 2012

leadership

According to the Taoist philosopher, Lao Tzu, “a leader is best when people barely know he exists, when his work is done, his aim fulfilled, they will say, we did it ourselves”.

That's a powerful reminder of a very different vision of the task and responsibility of leadership for our perplexing times - one that combines humility and compassion.

The notion leadership is a human attribute that should have a sense of collective or transcendent purpose is a far cry from the dominant economistic narrative of leadership which is largely defined in terms of material benefit to individuals, to corporations and to shareholders, to the exclusion of other interest groups and broader societal needs.

This excessively economistic focus on the tasks and responsibilities of management was a significant factor in the economic crisis that has left us in the turmoil we are in today. This bred a damaging individualism, at odds with any sense of stewardship or of collective or transcendent purpose, and a preoccupation with a very narrowly-defined 'bottom line'.

Leadership has been associated with unleashing individual entrepreneurial energies in highly-driven workplaces where each competed with all for career advancement. Business is seen as a form of war, a war of all against all and the workplace the battlefield where compassion, empathy and idealism are the fallen.

Leading business schools across the world have long emphasized that their fundamental role and responsibility is to create outstanding leaders. Yet the degree to which MBAs played key roles in this crisis only underlines the over-emphasis on economics and finance in the MBA curriculum and the need to develop fresh and different ways of thinking about and practising leadership that embrace a broader sense of personal identity, individual and collective possibility and intercultural awareness.

However, there is an alternative narrative of leadership, management and business which challenges the economic narrative which introduces the concepts of self- questioning, self-fashioning, identity, aspiration and hope. Rather than a philosophy of individualism, I would argue that the essence of being human is interconnection and interdependence which can be realized through authentic intercultural dialogue.

At the heart of this new vision is the notion of balance and the ability to create harmony in relationship with the self and others. Leaders need to balance economic necessity with the challenge of professing their humanity in developing more humane and sustainable organizations. That balancing act makes leadership a challenging activity which is, by its very nature, intellectual, emotional and spiritual. Leadership, we know to our cost, also has a shadow side. And so leadership needs to be viewed as a moral, ethical activity, best framed in terms of psychological and organizational integrity.

This interconnection goes beyond the bounds of the local and familiar to the transpersonal and spiritual. Authentic interconnectivity embraces similarity whilst celebrating difference; thus intercultural exchange becomes a vehicle for creating new learning spaces characterized by a respect and appreciation for difference and what it can teach us about ourselves.

Above all, then, leadership is as much an art as it is a science, as much a communal as an individual act. It is about dealing with an inherently complex, sometimes chaotic, psychologically challenging and always fast-moving, world. Increasingly, a major task leaders must accomplish is to create some sense of order and meaning out of chaos, both for themselves and for those they lead without succumbing to the temptation of premature closure and rigid thinking as a defence against the anxiety of uncertainty.

The most inspirational leaders display a willingness to be fully alert to and alive in the present moment and an attitude of mindfulness which promotes a deep intuitive appreciation of the patterns of experience in themselves and others. They are self-aware, possessing the capacity for deep, systematic reflection as well as an openness to sensory experience and embodied learning.

Encouraging this type of leadership requires us to integrate management and education best practice, eastern and western philosophy, psychology, the arts and humanities, systems thinking, action and narrative inquiry, story-telling, life histories, scenario planning, management learning and personal development.

Our overarching goal should be to facilitate the creation of more humane, more inclusive narratives of self, business and society that acknowledge that the social responsibility of business is much more than just increasing its profits.

Ken Starkey is professor of management and organisational learning at Nottingham University Business School

 

 

5 comments on this article

Your comment

Click here to comment

How refreshing...

Henrietta Flynn 31 Jan 2012

Thank you for such a refreshing take on the role of leaders and the challenges that underlie any successful leadership programme. Having taken a company through the Best Companies process over 5 years - increasing our ranking year on year - I am a strong advocate for a more transparent and human/humane approach to people management. And, as a graduate of social sciences at Nottingham University (many years ago), I was even more pleased when I saw where you're based!

Reframing the essence of leadership

Roger H Evans 31 Jan 2012

Thank you Ken Starkey At this time of global business turbulence and the public demand for leaders to demonstrate honesty, transparency and commitment to building a sustainable future this article is a timely challenge! to todays leaders and those concerned with the development of future leaders to reach for the essence of great human leadership and deeply reframe the leadership mindset as Starkey proposes.

A New Framework for Transcending Leadership

Pam Boney 01 Feb 2012

Thank you for writing this elegantly expressed article. We couldn't agree more and are working on this theory of leadership in the US in very practical ways. t have a google alert for transcendent or transcending leadership because my research is based on this theory of leadership, where positive self-concept is linked to positive climate in the enterprise through the phenomenon of transcending (purpose-focused) leadership. My research began in 1993 and we have a mental model and measure for how to develop identity strengths in leaders. Our goal is to shift the frame of thinking that got us into the economic crisis of today. Some MBA programs in the US are adopting our model and using it to teach in the curriculum. We would be delighted to share our research and models with anyone interested in this topic and interested in shaping a better world for our next generation of leaders. Pam Boney, Author & Chief Creative Officer, Tilt, Inc. http://tilt360leaders.com

Growing a New Leadership Landscape

Linda Berardi, MPA, SPHR 01 Feb 2012

What an inspiring read and one that aligns with our vision at WillowOak HR Consulting to grow strong, flexible teams through strength-based leadership. As a certified Appreciative Leadership Development Program (ALDP) facilitator through the Corporation for Positive Change (CPC) in Chapel Hill, North Carolina, and an HR/OD Consultant in the Greater Hampton Roads, Virginia area, we are breaking ground on this evolved leadership landscape.The ALDP developed by Diana Whitney, Ph.D., et.al., at CPC supports your point of view as a transformational leadership model based on David Cooperrider's work in Appreciative Inquiry. The ADLP embraces the value of "leading with" and the activation of its 5 principles - inquiry, inclusion, illumination, inspiration and integrity. These principles in action generate ripples of positive power from the positive core of individual leaders, teams, organizations and communities. I look forward to a day when a generative and inclusive leadership process grows strong roots in a world-wide business community and flourishes as leadership success stories are shared far and wide. Thank you Ken, for posting this conscious and effective new landscape for business growth and leadership development and adding humanity and humility to the prosperity equation.

A little respect

Peter Cook 07 Feb 2012

Great article - authenticity and humility are the DNA of leadership and HR in the post hubris era! I wrote a manifesto for plain, simple and authentic leadership in the form of my new micro book "Punk Rock People Management" - available free by mailing me via the link http://www.academy-of-rock.co.uk/Punk-Rock-HR Peter Cook

Latest Issue - May 2012

MA Business & Leisure Limited © Copyright 2012, All Rights Reserved