Features
Kevin Beales, 15 Aug 2011
Last month, says Kevin Beales, a Government report ‘exposed’ the estimated £275 million wasted on ineffectual training courses by the Civil Service. The National Audit Office estimated that hundreds of millions of pounds every year is wasted putting staff through expensive training courses that do not work.
Just £275 million! Really? I would suggest that is just the tip of the iceberg.
A meeting with a public sector prospect last week revealed that all employees, from the chief executive down, had a series of 'mandatory training courses' annually. But the challenge was that many never turned up, as they were unable to secure a parking spot for a course that started after 9am at their notoriously difficult to park HQ. And these attendees travelled throughout the county (I won't name names) to attend these courses – or not, as the case may be. Loss of productivity, wages and travel costs – and we haven't even started on the costs of training.
The 'sheep-dip' approach to training is, unfortunately, still alive and kicking. Yet simple pre-training assessments can highlight existing knowledge and eliminate training that clearly adds no value to an individual or the organisation, while still providing the audit trail of compliance that is the real driver behind many mandatory courses.
Better still, highlight any knowledge gaps and guide individuals to personalised learning where learning interventions – in the classroom, online or in available resources – can address training needs of any size without wasted time, effort and money.
While most leading companies have embraced the use of learning technologies to increase the effectiveness of learning and self-development, with notable exceptions, this adoption has been slower across the public sector. Perhaps it is the bureaucracy of such organisations that has failed to embrace the opportunities technology offers to eliminate 'ineffective training'. But in these times of austerity, does this not represent the perfect opportunity to provide learning interventions that genuinely develop individuals and organisational performance?
Of course, there is far more to effective training and personnel development than online assessments, e-learning and learning management systems. A learning culture that encourages social and informal learning, embraces self-development and fosters workplace learning is not achieved with technology alone. But to achieve such an organisational culture and maximise the impact of learning without the aid of technology is akin to climbing Everest while hopping.
So can the Civil Service embrace change to make training more effective? Our experience is that such change is almost always positively received by individuals. No-one wants to attend a course that they learn nothing from and often it is hard for an individual to recognise a training need or knowledge gap.
Assessing knowledge to determine training needs can also ensure a more receptive audience who know why they are there, recognising a development opportunity that will enhance their own and organisational performance. It also enables trainers to personalise courses based on results, areas to focus on and grouping those of similar existing knowledge and needs, increasing the impact and ROI of training (that can again be measured).
While accepting assessments and technology are just part of the answer, they are tools that can eliminate the recognised challenge across much of the Civil Service and help reduce the wasted money spent on ineffective training.
Kevin Beales is managing director of online assessment provider, The Test Factory
2 comments on this article |
Sam Barbee 19 Oct 2011
At Learning Pool we supply learning technology tools to over 200 councils in the UK and agree with a few of the points you have made. The learning culuture of the organisation is a a key apsect. You can have the tools in the world but if the culture isn't there it will all sit dormant. One of the things we do is engage with our customers and their workforce to identify ways that these tools will work for them. Using some of the examples you stated like pre-course assesment and social learning are good but the best is just getting out there to the people with the likes of launch events and surveys to show them what is available and how it can work for them. One of they ways that we help our customers move things forward is through the sharing that goes on in our community. We have over 7,000 members of our community and they regularsy share good practice on roll out, uptake, ROI and effectiveness of their e-learning on our forums and networking events. Technology is an enabler but it's still all about the people. www.learningpool.com
Latest Issue - May 2012
The myth of the axolotl is one of nature’s most fascinating.
MA Business & Leisure Limited © Copyright 2012, All Rights Reserved
Send to a friend